How do you get the shade just right without attempting to dye your eyebrows, you might ask? Brow pencils and brow gels prove especially handy here. "Finding the right base color of the brow hairs is most important, especially if you have stubborn light or white brow hairs," Glamsquad Artistic Director Kelli Bartlett said (via Makeup.com). Putting time into finding the right color brow pencil or gel will help you in the long run, and it will create a base over which you can build with pencils and gels of lighter and darker shades to create well-rounded, three dimensional brows that will wow yourself and others.
If you do want to go the dying route, though, Bartlett recommended dying your brows either blonde or brunette. She highlighted blonde brows for strawberry blondes and other lighter shades of hair, and brunette brows if your hair is a deeper shade of red. These add dimension to your face in ways that having both red brows and hair doesn't.
Overall, using brow pencils and gels are the easiest route to go down for highlighting your brows, but other options do exist, such as brow tinting (via LiveAbout).